Mallorys Elegy
Mallory
A flower in a box is no flower at all
On what would have been our eighth wedding anniversary, I wanted to share my last letter to Mallory, which officially ended our marriage. This and my brother’s death were the hardest things I’ve been asked to undergo.
Mallory, I’m going to break your heart. I think I’ve actually already broken it a thousand times on a hundred different days. Do you remember how I said you wouldn’t have to feel loneliness’s sting? I meant that. I will always love you and be there for you, and to this day, I think of you every night before I fall asleep. We need to separate. I need to let you be free. I’m sorry I’ve held you back.
I kept trying to beat around the bush because I was scared, but I’ve just made it worse and broken your heart for a hundred more days by being unable to just get it out. We aren’t right for each other. You’re my best friend and my oldest ally; I haven’t treated you right; you haven’t treated me right; what we want in life doesn’t align; I love you. I love you — that’s why this has been so hard.
I didn’t want to see you cry again. I’ve made you cry a hundred times since I first thought that. I feel like I’ve led you on and wasted years of your life when I knew this would be the outcome. I’m sorry.
I don’t want you to think that I did all this in some quest to preserve what was going to be lost. I went through all those years of therapy that wasn’t working, the long talks, getting pets, and moving because I wanted it to work. I wanted something to fix what was wrong between us. I wanted something to fix what was wrong in our lives. What I learned, though, is that I’m grateful I could be there when you needed me. I’m grateful now for being able to let you be free of me to find what you need next. I truly, with all my heart, wish it could be me. The way I live my life, it can’t be, and I won’t drag you through it with me anymore.
You might not see it now, and you may never see it, but I truly believe I’m giving you the opportunity to be free. I got to see you heal; I got to see you get your degrees; I got to see you come back to yourself; you got to see me feel like me again. We had Christmases and birthdays and anniversaries and trips, but I think we both knew that there was something off. It stopped being easy once things weren’t hard. You wanted easy, and I couldn’t live without the hard. I want you to get to have easy.
I don’t want to go on and on, so here are my last words. You deserve what will make you happy in the life you choose. You kept telling me you chose to fight for us and that you’ll always be with me. I want you to choose to fight for you. Us has been destructive and hurtful, but also joyful and healing. Now that we’re both back to us, I think I’ve realized us is not us. I can’t hold you back anymore, and I know that you won’t do this without me forcing the point because you’re scared of life without me. I’ll tell you two things.
I’ll always be there if you ever need me, and I’ll be only one call away; I promise you with all my heart that will never change. I could be on the other side of the world, but if my best friend needs me, she’ll have me as soon as I can get a flight. I love you.
You deserve something that’s not me. You deserve not to have to be uprooted and taken on my journey of dissatisfaction. You deserve to plant roots and see yourself grow. You’re happier and nicer when I’m not around. We both know it, but we’re too afraid to say it; I can see it in your eyes when you look at me. I can’t look anymore.
Leave this last sentence under your pillow — “I love you, and I always will, and there’s a world where I’m the man you deserve, but I need to let you live this life in the way that will make you fulfilled. I wish that was with me.”
As a gift to myself I’ll let myself admit the one thing I’ve been holding back. I resent Mallory for making me do this alone and putting all of the emotional consequences on me. We built the house together but when it came down I had to be the one to point it out. I don’t think I can ever forgive you for that. I love you.