Poetic Insomniac
I’m unable to rest tonight. I’ve been trying to fall asleep for three hours. Insomnia isn’t a running of the mind, it’s sitting in the dark with your eyes closed and nothing running through your mind but you are refused any rest. When I can’t rest I’ll quote Leonard Cohen, "The last refuge of the insomniac is a sense of superiority to the sleeping world.” — let’s do a very small critique of contemporary poetry and by extension modern writing.
I want to preface — you will be able to find counter-examples to what I’ll lay out but I argue, with little evidence available at 1:30am, it is more common than not.
In Math you being proofs with assumptions based on other proofs. These are formally assumed to be fact in your mental model as they have been supplemented by modeled by other proofs. In the formal discipline these are generally called lemma. I’ll take my single opportunity in the past year to use my Ph.D and lay out a few lemma.
I made my actual Ph.Ds into placemats, they’re laminated and sitting on my table. I always use the math one, makes me feel superior.
Lemma One: Modern poetry is inherently free-verse. Opening contemporary poetry books you will generally not encounter rhyme or meter or even musicality. A really good example is Langston Hughes who as an incredible artist purposefully embraced free-verse in order to reject European poetic traditions. I encourage you to read (I too)[https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47558/i-too] not just for the incredibly moving and simple message of black empowerment but to see a skilled free-verse poet.
Lemma Two: Modern poetry is inherently theatric. When I read poets in a place like Only Poems I generally come to the conclusion a writer is telling building a scene. My best example is my personal favorite author Ilya Kaminsky. Kaminsky’s work can be thought of as a fundamentally theatrical author who moves realty to theatre and this works incredibly with recurring motifs such as verteps (Ukrainian puppet theatre).
Lemma Three: Modern poetry is story telling. I see very few poems, novellas, or novels published now a-days that are not what I will call story telling. Story telling represents direct plot and progression, it disregards loops or abstractions or more ephemeral conceptions of literary work. You can will always be able to find works that don’t fit into this but if you examine the books in a Barnes and Noble or Books A Million (rip) it’s hard to find non story telling.
I’m going to spend another paragraph on this lemma because we need to frame the counter-example. A novel doesn’t have to directly tell a story. You can look at an orange and warp into a manifestation of time like in Molasses Black Oranges and have no story unfold. There are no characters or plot or movements or dramatic tension. It never says to you who’s speaking or what they’re saying. An orange sits on a table and our imagination takes hold. That’s not story telling it’s observational and surreal. These are not mutually exclusive but modern works tend to favor the former and it’s relatively difficult for a modern reader to get into the later if they’re not specifically searching.
With our lemma established I’m going to make the case for why this is a failure of modern literature and poetry specifically. The motivation for this revelation on modern writings roadblock comes from a comment I got on a poem, “this was hard for me to parse maybe you could try more direct story telling.” Sometimes emotions are hard and that’s the point. I understand it’s not your style but abstraction has value.
—
Argument 1 — abstraction has value
Let me define abstraction first through what Math represents. This is something every one of my students, undergrad through graduate, struggled with when I was their advisor. Not to give a diatribe but this is a hill to die on, Math is not equations or functions or curves. You have to stop thinking about oranges and apples and triangles and think instead ask things like “What is an orange and how is it also an Apple?” or “Is a cup a mug? Is a mug a donut?” or further “What is a donut?” or another question “How do I define a donut?” or one you cannot answer “What tangles of donuts cannot exist?". My specialty of topology doesn’t answer these questions it attempts to create models for these questions, that means it asks itself how do we even know what questions to ask of spaces. That’s abstraction.
Abstraction in our sense can be best demonstrated in the same way. You pull on the threads on your story or object until there is nothing left but the concept. You’ve taken the reader on a journey of you discovering what the core of an object or scene is truly about. The magic is their abstraction is not your abstraction and the wizardy continues because their abstraction has created a whole other meaning and universe you could have never predicted.
I don’t want someone to read Molasses Black Oranges and know it’s about my suicidal thoughts. I want them to feel it and connect themselves. I’ve abstracted the orange into a representation of depression or unease and let them sit with that abstract feeling to come to their own conclusion. The orange is merely the vehicle to evoke the emotion I was experiencing in the reader. You’ve gotten past the rind to the rotten center.
People now-a-days will debate the specific usage of you in a poem and how the point of view of that word changes the meaning but these are surface level abstractions. The character is still there and it might be you or me or some other third character but it has not left the world of the scene behind. You haven’t felt what you could have felt had the directions not told you your part. I read a poem recently by a Palestinian author, I unfortunately can’t recall their name. It was a good poem, well maybe bad, about running through a hospital holding a child already dead. The you that was used in that poem implied the narrator felt alive, the child felt still alive, or a generic person felt alive but only while running in urgency.
I won’t critique this work too hard because it does what it was trying to do extremely well, it puts the reader in the place of story through multiple different perspectives and parts. That is a very artistic way to demonstrate to the reader the emotional consequences of violence through all involved. When a girl next to me went “mmm, that’s so powerful” I could only think to myself ‘you only see because it’s told straight to your face. If it whispered would you still wonder what was said?’. There’s art in both and with abstraction you’d lose immediacy and some readers who won’t engage if it’s not directly there but you also have to think about what you’ve lost. That Palestinian girls story has now become a tale of a specific instance, which is incredibly valuable, but she has lost her ability to be a broader concept. Maybe that’s better, but it’s a question worth asking.
I want to propose the counter example to the immediacy and let the reader decide if my argument has merit. I’ve gone through war too so I feel justified in making these alternatives. The girl in the arms of the narrator — what if she’s not a girl? What if instead we get past the girl and look at the innocence of the child instead? Can we frame her as cultural staple of Palestine? Maybe the girl becomes a plate of Shakshuka when her veins burst and then a memory of a moment prayer where the smell of food wafted through the air? Does telling me running makes the perspectives feel alive do more to evoke life than saying something along the lines of?
When shakshuka spills from the pot in your arms — Jaddah seems to call from across the house.
This is another authors work so it is there expression to define but for readers I’ll ask which makes you feel it faster and which makes you feel it longer? Which scares you like a jump scare and which gives you a creeping dread?
That’s the value in abstraction. You transform something from a forcing function that places the reader in a space and makes them inhabit it to forcing them to build their own space with the same emotions you felt at the time. It unfortunately is a dying and less popular art form but maybe that’s for the best because it’s inherently less immediately accessible. I watched a girl read four stanzas of my book and put it down and tell her friend it didn’t make sense. I think she’d make sense easier of this other authors work. Would it stick with her as long?
There’s another counter-argument here that I myself have experienced during our own war just a bit further north. Does turning this girl into a lost meal and memory risk losing her specific identity? Does this girl deserve to be memorialized as some larger concept or can she be allowed to just be her? I think about Roman in this instance as a relation, do I want him to be a broader casualty or still my brother? I want him to be both because there’s a million Max’s out there who lost their Roman’s too. I’m tired so I’m going to leave this on draft but my desire is that she lives in the memory of her family and those who loved her with their experiences but that is also allowed to be planted for others who’ve lost their sons and daughters and family so she can give them shade when they need it. I’ll explain more tomorrow.